In Part I of this post, I had set the context for understanding uncertainty and its impact. Part II looks specifically at uncertainty and scale-up.
Generally we give a lot of attention to business uncertainty, but seldom do we give sufficient attention to operational uncertainty that is faced by the team members on their day work. Managing such operational uncertainty therefore is a very critical factor when we attempt to scale up any operation or any business.
Normally the core team that set up any operation or business successfully will consist of highly motivated, highly skilled, high performance individuals who are comfortable in decision making under uncertainty. Once the operations are on steam and ready to scale up we need to work with a different set of people. We cannot afford to have the same calibre people when the operation is scaled-up. It is not just a question of financial affordability; such people will not survive long in a regular operational environment. They are normally impatient lot and in constant search for new dreams.
Therefore we have to have processes to get work with ordinary, risk averse, simple people who want to be led. As Lee Iacocca pointed out “if you are a brilliant person you may be able to do the work of 30 people; but if you are a brilliant leader who can get work out of 1000 ordinary people and then you achieve much more”
One of the major weaknesses of normal people is their inability or discomfort to take decision under uncertainty. They need clear algorithm on how to address each eventuality. In the absence of such clear standard operating procedures (SOP), many people avoid taking decisions or become inefficient in taking decisions. In this case they are almost like computer software that hangs in the absence of sub routines to handle all cases. As in the case of elegant computer programs, the SOPs should have dependable error handling, clear exception reporting and escalation rules in place for un-programmed cases. Otherwise system hangs or misbehaves. Only then we can scale –up with “Intel people” like Google scale up with “Intel boxes”
We have to accept the reality that the vast majority of people need clear delineation of tasks to help them achieve maximum productivity. As Chris Argyris observes in the article ‘Empowerment: The Emperor’s New Clothes’ published in Harvard Business Review “Both research and practice indicate that the best results of reengineering occur when the jobs are rigorously specified and not when individuals are left to define them”
The first thing we need to do in our endeavour to reduce uncertainty is to map organizational goals to group deliverables and break down group deliverables preferably up to the individual level. Once the deliverables are broken down, then we should try to develop standard operating procedure or business rules for as many cases as possible. This has to be a continuous process and there should be process in place to continuously identify cases where SOPs or business rules are developed.
One of the risks when we have processes that depend on SOPs heavily is that the people get to be process oriented instead of result oriented. This is one of the major weaknesses of bureaucracy. It is here that we need to teach human beings to also use his human intelligence and not to behave like computer programs. We should clearly teach each person and team to appreciate what the SOPs are trying to achieve as results. We should empower the process owners to innovate and improvise on the SOPs when there are exceptions. Here again we should try to provide boundary conditions within which they have to flexibility. This will reduce uncertainty even with flexibility.
On the other hand we should also work towards helping people to learn the art of being comfortable under uncertainty because human beings who can make sensible judgement under uncertainty are key assets in any team. Although genetic trait influences this skill quite a lot, this is still a skill that can be strengthened by training and support.
We should also have a way to identify and encourage people who are adept at this skill. Most importantly we should ensure that people who rise up to leadership are the people who can handle uncertainty and also who can reduce uncertainty for their team. It is here that many organisations fail. They get impressed by people who have delivered excellent results based on their skill and knowledge in situations or functions where ambient uncertainty is low. Then we promote them to levels where they have to mange uncertainty which are outside their domain of expertise. This happens very often with respect to technical people. Then these poor souls (smart engineers, doctors, lawyers, accountants) like fish out of water fail and the whole team suffers.
When we develop our scale-up strategies this is one dimension we forget and we focus on everything else like process, technology, people, finance and so on. We have to include operational uncertainty management as a key dimension with which we qualify our scale-up strategies. Else the best of strategies will fail on account of minds that freeze under uncertain outcomes.
Beyond all this theory lie commitment, conviction and faith that is beautifully described in alchemist “If you believe in something the whole world will conspire to make it happen for you”.
“Nothing great has ever been achieved except by those who dared believe that something inside them was superior to circumstances.” Bruce Barton
The weekly series that will make you think, laugh and cry. Don't miss. Bookmark this page
Monday, May 17, 2010
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Scaling up;The Art of the Impossible - Part I
There is one thing certain in our life; and that is uncertainty. Uncertainty about of life, our future, our family; everything in our life is uncertain. Most people are not comfortable to deal with uncertainty. But we have learned to accept such uncertainties on which we have absolutely no control, with certain amount of equanimity. Sometimes some of us try to reduce uncertainty about our future by visiting an astrologer, palm reader, so on and so forth. Linda Goodman and her ilk have made fortunes for themselves by exploiting this fear of uncertainty.
When it comes to areas where we have some control, like education, career, wealth etc, we are more uncomfortable with uncertainty. One of the primary reasons why we go to colleges and acquire degrees is to reduce uncertainty in our life. When we take up employment in a company instead of starting our own, we are trying to reduce uncertainty because the company has taken many of the key decisions with respect to the line of business, technology, product, process etc and we form a part of the team in implementing the strategies that have already been decided. Even in this case there may be still high level uncertainty as we go up in the ladder and/ or if we have direct business responsibility. When we take up a career in government we are still reducing uncertainty, as normally there is very limited systemic compulsion for results (as against process compliance) in many of the bureaucratic positions. (But there are many bureaucrats who try to do justice to their inner compulsion to make a difference)
I once did an experiment with a large group of my colleagues as a part of our internal training program. I gave three problems to all the participants and asked them to choose one problem they would take up to solve. The first problem was long, it had quite a lot of brute force computation to do; but the algorithm was sort of clear. The second problem was a logical puzzle. In this case the end result was quite measurable; it was evident that there would be an algorithm to solve, though the algorithm was not clear. The third problem had no clear algorithm or no one right answer. Most of the people chose problem 1, and only few chose problem 3. This kind of result will be common among most of the people.
There is one thing certain about uncertainty; that the success of any idea or project or company or organization is highly dependent on how we manage uncertainty for ourselves and for our teams.
To be continued ....
Certainty is the mother of quiet and repose, and uncertainty the cause of variance and contentions. Edward Coke
When it comes to areas where we have some control, like education, career, wealth etc, we are more uncomfortable with uncertainty. One of the primary reasons why we go to colleges and acquire degrees is to reduce uncertainty in our life. When we take up employment in a company instead of starting our own, we are trying to reduce uncertainty because the company has taken many of the key decisions with respect to the line of business, technology, product, process etc and we form a part of the team in implementing the strategies that have already been decided. Even in this case there may be still high level uncertainty as we go up in the ladder and/ or if we have direct business responsibility. When we take up a career in government we are still reducing uncertainty, as normally there is very limited systemic compulsion for results (as against process compliance) in many of the bureaucratic positions. (But there are many bureaucrats who try to do justice to their inner compulsion to make a difference)
I once did an experiment with a large group of my colleagues as a part of our internal training program. I gave three problems to all the participants and asked them to choose one problem they would take up to solve. The first problem was long, it had quite a lot of brute force computation to do; but the algorithm was sort of clear. The second problem was a logical puzzle. In this case the end result was quite measurable; it was evident that there would be an algorithm to solve, though the algorithm was not clear. The third problem had no clear algorithm or no one right answer. Most of the people chose problem 1, and only few chose problem 3. This kind of result will be common among most of the people.
There is one thing certain about uncertainty; that the success of any idea or project or company or organization is highly dependent on how we manage uncertainty for ourselves and for our teams.
To be continued ....
Certainty is the mother of quiet and repose, and uncertainty the cause of variance and contentions. Edward Coke
Monday, May 3, 2010
It is for me to choose
“It was my fate”, “It was destined to happen” are comments we often hear when something unexpected happens. Such comments suggest that we are a part of a giant puppet show in which things happen as per a supreme design and we have no control on what happens. Usually, such thoughts console us when things go wrong; because the failure was not on account of our shortcoming, not on account of our irresponsible behaviour, not on account of the evil deeds of some, but because it was ‘so destined’.
On the other hand, most of our formal social systems like the legal system, the education system and the performance evaluation system are administered on the basis that we have the complete capability and freedom to choose our (re)actions and behaviour. If we break the law, we can’t escape the penalty claiming that it was destined. This is sort of a paradox; the mental balance propped by our faith in fate and will of a supreme force and the social balance supported by a structure that assumes rational choice by every human being. In our day-to-day life we often vacillate between these two extremes.
I decided to think through a bit and take a view that could guide the way I interpret events and act upon them. I agree with the brilliant one line summary by Jawaharlal Nehru; “Life is like a game of cards. The hand you are dealt is determinism; the way you play it is freewill.”
We live in a totally inter-connected world. What we do out of our freewill could set off a series of chain reactions like what happens on the snooker board. Sometimes we get the shot right and the outcome is as predicted. Very often the chain reactions we trigger bring about a new order on the board which we never imagined; as expressed by the butterfly effect, based on chaos theory, made popular by the paper by Philip Merilees titled “Does the flap of a butterfly’s wings in Brazil set off a tornado in Texas?”
Some crazy kid decides to take his car for a spin. It was his free will. I happened to be in his way and got hit; it was my destiny. I survive with two artificial limbs; it is my destiny. I now have two choices. I can try to live on and find happiness in spite of my broken leg or can spent the life cursing the crazy kid and live a life of regret despair. Here I need to exercise my freewill.
This framework of freewill helps me to appreciate the fact that even though I have the freewill to choose, the options available to me are outcomes of a large number of factors on which I have no control and sometime the choice that we take makes it possible to predict how things turnout. It also teaches me that the freewill to choose does not guarantee any outcome; but I am still responsible for the choice.
How I exercise my freewill is also dependent on my mental makeup and strength. If I let myself to grow up without taking responsibility of my action then I may not be able to exercise freewill to the extent that is needed in any occasion. From this point of view freewill needs to be nurtured consciously and worked upon.
We can build up this skill as we build on our muscles. There could be limit on our ability to build on various skills; which could be on account of our DNA structure. But as we have to exercise regularly to develop a healthy body, we have to work on to strengthen how we react to what happens around us.
One of the true marks of achievement in life is the way we master this art of exercising our choice.
“The annoying thing about believing in free will and individual responsibility is the difficulty of finding somebody to blame our problems on." P. J. O'Rourke
On the other hand, most of our formal social systems like the legal system, the education system and the performance evaluation system are administered on the basis that we have the complete capability and freedom to choose our (re)actions and behaviour. If we break the law, we can’t escape the penalty claiming that it was destined. This is sort of a paradox; the mental balance propped by our faith in fate and will of a supreme force and the social balance supported by a structure that assumes rational choice by every human being. In our day-to-day life we often vacillate between these two extremes.
I decided to think through a bit and take a view that could guide the way I interpret events and act upon them. I agree with the brilliant one line summary by Jawaharlal Nehru; “Life is like a game of cards. The hand you are dealt is determinism; the way you play it is freewill.”
We live in a totally inter-connected world. What we do out of our freewill could set off a series of chain reactions like what happens on the snooker board. Sometimes we get the shot right and the outcome is as predicted. Very often the chain reactions we trigger bring about a new order on the board which we never imagined; as expressed by the butterfly effect, based on chaos theory, made popular by the paper by Philip Merilees titled “Does the flap of a butterfly’s wings in Brazil set off a tornado in Texas?”
Some crazy kid decides to take his car for a spin. It was his free will. I happened to be in his way and got hit; it was my destiny. I survive with two artificial limbs; it is my destiny. I now have two choices. I can try to live on and find happiness in spite of my broken leg or can spent the life cursing the crazy kid and live a life of regret despair. Here I need to exercise my freewill.
This framework of freewill helps me to appreciate the fact that even though I have the freewill to choose, the options available to me are outcomes of a large number of factors on which I have no control and sometime the choice that we take makes it possible to predict how things turnout. It also teaches me that the freewill to choose does not guarantee any outcome; but I am still responsible for the choice.
How I exercise my freewill is also dependent on my mental makeup and strength. If I let myself to grow up without taking responsibility of my action then I may not be able to exercise freewill to the extent that is needed in any occasion. From this point of view freewill needs to be nurtured consciously and worked upon.
We can build up this skill as we build on our muscles. There could be limit on our ability to build on various skills; which could be on account of our DNA structure. But as we have to exercise regularly to develop a healthy body, we have to work on to strengthen how we react to what happens around us.
One of the true marks of achievement in life is the way we master this art of exercising our choice.
“The annoying thing about believing in free will and individual responsibility is the difficulty of finding somebody to blame our problems on." P. J. O'Rourke
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Regulation of Innovation and Innovative Regulation
“In 1898, delegates from across the globe gathered in New York City for the world’s first international urban planning conference. One topic dominated the discussion. It was not housing, land use, economic development, or infrastructure. The delegates were driven to desperation by horse manure. The situation seemed dire. In 1894, the Times of London estimated that by 1950 every street in the city would be buried nine feet deep in horse manure.” (From Horse Power to Horsepower -Eric Morris)
Domestication of horse has been one of the key contributors of human progress; as it provided logistics support for business, leisure, pleasure and even conquests. We are good at building on and exploiting anything that would maximise our private benefits that sooner than later the negative externalities start taking a toll to the society at large; what the economists call the tragedy of the commons.
This happened in case of Horse Power too. With exponential growth in horse drawn logistics, by the end of 19th century accidents, pollution, and health hazards associated with horse was scary and appeared un-controllable.
Then came internal combustion engines that were much less polluting (even the methane produced by horse manure is eight times more potent than CO2 from automobiles as a greenhouse gas) less accident prone, much faster and more powerful. But by the end of 20th century this saviour has grown to a monster that is ready to savour its creator as it has proliferated to almost unsustainable levels.
The same is true for most of the human innovations. In financial services the time taken for an innovation of graduate to a Frankenstein has been quite low.
For examples derivatives have been developed as a tool for hedging risk. It has grown to be an instrument not infrequently used to structure products with the sole intention of profiting from the unsuspecting investors. Credit Default Swaps and Securitisation of debt instruments contributed enormously to the maturing of debt markets and helped better resource allocation. But this was also taken to its ridiculous extent that in most cases there was nobody who really cared or owned up responsibility to assess the true cost and risks associated with the underlying assets. The recent indictment of Goldman Sachs is an example of such unfair practices.
Does it mean that we need to curtail innovations? The answer is no. It is these innovations that ensured that the Malthusian theory has turned out to be an imaginary fear and the standard of living of a significant majority of human beings across the globe is hundreds of times better than the best the select few enjoyed even a few decades ago.
But as the time goes, products of these innovations reach such gargantuan proportions with very high impact on the well being of the society especially in a ‘flat world’ as described by Thomas Friedman. With large segment of wealth under the control of few large entities who are ‘too big to fail’, the difficulty of reining their run-way exploitation of their innovations gets to be even more difficult.
Addressing these is one of the key challenges for any government. Towards this goal, firstly we need to support strong regulations and stronger regulators who do not fall prey to their megalomaniacal instincts and try to micro-manage or centrally control; but who have the intellectual capability to analyse issues to identify key levers for action, recognize practices that exploit the common investors and curtail them, have courage to take strong and often unpopular decisions, can make the institutions who screw-up to pay-up and has moral strength not to be influenced by money, power or influence and at the same time is capable to encourage and get out of the way of innovations that are game changers. The stand taken by SEBI recently with respect to Unit Linked Insurance Policies (ULIP) which is a mutual fund masquerading as insurance is an excellent case in point on the constructive role the regulator can play.
Secondly we need to enable, encourage and empower disruptive technologies, processes and products that solve problems that are critical to survival of humanity. Especially since the existing interest groups who have heavily invested in the old system will work overtime to prevent success of these innovations. For example the oil industry will be happy to ensure that till the last drop of oil is left, human beings are addicted to it and are willing to pay more and more for the less and less that is drilled or excavated out. We experienced similar resistance from custodians and registrars when we were setting up a depository for Indian Capital Market.
The governments have a major role to play here too. They have to support, encourage, fund and place enabling provisions so that innovations are allowed to take root and reach a critical mass. Only then these disruptive technologies, products and processes can manage to break the status-quo and establish better, cleaner, more efficient solutions to problems that appear to make human race a run way experiment that is ready to destroy the mother earth as we know today.
That is why the two principal challenges for the day are Regulation of Innovation and Innovative Regulation
"It has yet to be proven that intelligence has any survival value." — Arthur C. Clarke
Domestication of horse has been one of the key contributors of human progress; as it provided logistics support for business, leisure, pleasure and even conquests. We are good at building on and exploiting anything that would maximise our private benefits that sooner than later the negative externalities start taking a toll to the society at large; what the economists call the tragedy of the commons.
This happened in case of Horse Power too. With exponential growth in horse drawn logistics, by the end of 19th century accidents, pollution, and health hazards associated with horse was scary and appeared un-controllable.
Then came internal combustion engines that were much less polluting (even the methane produced by horse manure is eight times more potent than CO2 from automobiles as a greenhouse gas) less accident prone, much faster and more powerful. But by the end of 20th century this saviour has grown to a monster that is ready to savour its creator as it has proliferated to almost unsustainable levels.
The same is true for most of the human innovations. In financial services the time taken for an innovation of graduate to a Frankenstein has been quite low.
For examples derivatives have been developed as a tool for hedging risk. It has grown to be an instrument not infrequently used to structure products with the sole intention of profiting from the unsuspecting investors. Credit Default Swaps and Securitisation of debt instruments contributed enormously to the maturing of debt markets and helped better resource allocation. But this was also taken to its ridiculous extent that in most cases there was nobody who really cared or owned up responsibility to assess the true cost and risks associated with the underlying assets. The recent indictment of Goldman Sachs is an example of such unfair practices.
Does it mean that we need to curtail innovations? The answer is no. It is these innovations that ensured that the Malthusian theory has turned out to be an imaginary fear and the standard of living of a significant majority of human beings across the globe is hundreds of times better than the best the select few enjoyed even a few decades ago.
But as the time goes, products of these innovations reach such gargantuan proportions with very high impact on the well being of the society especially in a ‘flat world’ as described by Thomas Friedman. With large segment of wealth under the control of few large entities who are ‘too big to fail’, the difficulty of reining their run-way exploitation of their innovations gets to be even more difficult.
Addressing these is one of the key challenges for any government. Towards this goal, firstly we need to support strong regulations and stronger regulators who do not fall prey to their megalomaniacal instincts and try to micro-manage or centrally control; but who have the intellectual capability to analyse issues to identify key levers for action, recognize practices that exploit the common investors and curtail them, have courage to take strong and often unpopular decisions, can make the institutions who screw-up to pay-up and has moral strength not to be influenced by money, power or influence and at the same time is capable to encourage and get out of the way of innovations that are game changers. The stand taken by SEBI recently with respect to Unit Linked Insurance Policies (ULIP) which is a mutual fund masquerading as insurance is an excellent case in point on the constructive role the regulator can play.
Secondly we need to enable, encourage and empower disruptive technologies, processes and products that solve problems that are critical to survival of humanity. Especially since the existing interest groups who have heavily invested in the old system will work overtime to prevent success of these innovations. For example the oil industry will be happy to ensure that till the last drop of oil is left, human beings are addicted to it and are willing to pay more and more for the less and less that is drilled or excavated out. We experienced similar resistance from custodians and registrars when we were setting up a depository for Indian Capital Market.
The governments have a major role to play here too. They have to support, encourage, fund and place enabling provisions so that innovations are allowed to take root and reach a critical mass. Only then these disruptive technologies, products and processes can manage to break the status-quo and establish better, cleaner, more efficient solutions to problems that appear to make human race a run way experiment that is ready to destroy the mother earth as we know today.
That is why the two principal challenges for the day are Regulation of Innovation and Innovative Regulation
"It has yet to be proven that intelligence has any survival value." — Arthur C. Clarke
Monday, April 19, 2010
To be or Not to be – Part III - Tharoor’s Dilemma
After eleven months in the office, Shahi Tharoor has stepped down from the post of Minister of State for External Affairs. Everybody knows the reason. It was not his ability to perform that cost him the post. He, instead of being an asset in the parliament for the ruling party, became a liability on account of the way he has conducted himself on a few occasions.
I don’t believe that he was corrupt, I don’t know whether his ‘transgression’ compared to the standards of some of the politicians are anything extraordinary, I don’t know whether compared to the loot of public finance that many in the ruling class perpetrate, Tharoor benefitted in any financial sense; though the there are questions on the nature of sweat that paid for certain equity.
For a seasoned diplomat with decades of experience in international diplomacy his failure is that he forgot an age old dictum; “Caesar’s wife has to be above suspicion”. Natural question is whether all our “Caesars' wives are above suspicion”
There is one big difference here. Tharoor was trying to muscle into a club, banking on a different skill set and preaching a different value system. On the basis of these credentials he had managed to take an express elevator to the position of power and influence in Indian politics. It has caused jealousy pangs among many who had been waiting in the wings for years, it has caused concerns among some established veterans about the changes propounded by people like him, it has caused worries that the apple cart is tilting. It was natural that the empire would strike back.
When he embarked on such a challenge he should have been a bit more careful; especially when he was yet to establish a strong support base who would have stood up for him. He should have shown more discretion and tried to avoid anything that could be misconstrued as pushing private agendas.
Now he has two choices. Work on building the support base and fight on the position of strength. Or join the club on their terms. This is standard operating procedure for any new entrant at the top. Or he can decide to retire and take up less risky hobbies like sky diving...
“Serious sport has nothing to do with fair play. It is bound up with hatred, jealousy, boastfulness, disregard of all rules and sadistic pleasure in witnessing violence. In other words, it is war minus the shooting". George Orwell.
Politics could be more demanding than any serious sport.
I don’t believe that he was corrupt, I don’t know whether his ‘transgression’ compared to the standards of some of the politicians are anything extraordinary, I don’t know whether compared to the loot of public finance that many in the ruling class perpetrate, Tharoor benefitted in any financial sense; though the there are questions on the nature of sweat that paid for certain equity.
For a seasoned diplomat with decades of experience in international diplomacy his failure is that he forgot an age old dictum; “Caesar’s wife has to be above suspicion”. Natural question is whether all our “Caesars' wives are above suspicion”
There is one big difference here. Tharoor was trying to muscle into a club, banking on a different skill set and preaching a different value system. On the basis of these credentials he had managed to take an express elevator to the position of power and influence in Indian politics. It has caused jealousy pangs among many who had been waiting in the wings for years, it has caused concerns among some established veterans about the changes propounded by people like him, it has caused worries that the apple cart is tilting. It was natural that the empire would strike back.
When he embarked on such a challenge he should have been a bit more careful; especially when he was yet to establish a strong support base who would have stood up for him. He should have shown more discretion and tried to avoid anything that could be misconstrued as pushing private agendas.
Now he has two choices. Work on building the support base and fight on the position of strength. Or join the club on their terms. This is standard operating procedure for any new entrant at the top. Or he can decide to retire and take up less risky hobbies like sky diving...
“Serious sport has nothing to do with fair play. It is bound up with hatred, jealousy, boastfulness, disregard of all rules and sadistic pleasure in witnessing violence. In other words, it is war minus the shooting". George Orwell.
Politics could be more demanding than any serious sport.
Sunday, April 11, 2010
One good reason to blog
When I took to writing a blog, two of my friends had strong reservations. One is a senior banker who believes that he is more an economist (he apparently reads quite a number of books on economics and spends a lot of time in the hallowed company of economists) and other an economist by training, thoughts and deeds. They came to a conclusion that I should avoid attempting this venture. The reason, my academic credentials on economics are not good enough to write on topics like public policy or management of financial services which have relation with economics. I completely agree with them about my academic credentials in economics.
This conflict of academic elitism and managerial pragmatism is a reality of life. Many academics tend to take the path of extreme specialisation that they are incapable to grapple with multi-disciplinary challenges of real world. They hide themselves in specialised jargon and restrictive logic of “ceteris paribus” that while much of what they say are sensible, it fails to make sense to those who are expected to act on it. In fact many of these academic high priests behave as if it is below their dignity to articulate their theories in a manner the common man (even an educated manager) can understand. Some of them seem to think that the world is made up of only rational economic agents analysing myriad decision variables in real-time leading to best possible outcome. Such elitism is still tolerable in music, literature, drama etc But in applied sciences like economics, management etc., unless it connects with the practitioners it will fail to have real value except to satisfy a few ego trips
If they don’t find a way to reach across to the guy who is expected to practice the theories they propound, how can they expect those thoughts to be more widely accepted? If they don’t find a way to fathom the life and challenges of the practitioners, how can they evolve solutions that are acceptable? If they don’t understand the inner fears, insecurities and private agendas and work around them, how can they implement policies that are game changers?
On the other hand the managers and administrators hide their laziness to be up-to-date and unwillingness to think-through, under their complaints on impracticability of the academic thoughts. They are happy with the networking dinners, what the various vendors and interest groups are keen to convince them or their boss’s whims. The more ‘professional manager’ or the more senior in the bureaucratic ladder they are, the more intransigent and intellectually sterile they make themselves. Quick results at whatever cost instead of institution building become the norm than an exception.
Our educational institutions, even the elite ones, fail to bridge this chasm to any meaningful extent. Our schools focus primarily on the ability to memorise and regurgitate answers to a bank of potential questions that may come for the exams. The colleges follow the same route too and the kids forget everything the moment the exams are over because the focus is more on marks than on what is learned. We can’t blame them as none of the teachings are contextual and most fail to demonstrate any relevance. Then the schools and colleges become just tools to attain a degree which itself is nothing but a pre-requisite to open many doors.
My blog is my attempt to address this conflict within me; the conflict between practical compulsions and theoretical possibilities. The blog for me is not a log of my private life laid bare to the public voyeurism as a means of keeping in touch. It is a tool that forces me to work on a thought and think-through its nuances for a few hours; crossing the ‘t’s and dotting the ‘i’s, which helps to bring some more clarity in my mind. It also throws open, to peer scrutiny, criticism and appreciation, my interpretations and how I use this learning (or the lack of it) and interpretations in tackling day-to-day challenges.
When I get your comments or thoughts or experiences on related issues, (I get many private mails in response to my postings and it appears that many are not comfortable to take a public position, may be eventually they will) it could offer another avenue,for both of us, to benefit from the “wisdom of the crowds” at very little cost. Some academicians willing to skim through these ramblings may also get some ideas on how to “win and influence” the guys in the trenches.
The illiterate of the 21st century will not be those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn, and relearn. ALVIN TOFFLER
This conflict of academic elitism and managerial pragmatism is a reality of life. Many academics tend to take the path of extreme specialisation that they are incapable to grapple with multi-disciplinary challenges of real world. They hide themselves in specialised jargon and restrictive logic of “ceteris paribus” that while much of what they say are sensible, it fails to make sense to those who are expected to act on it. In fact many of these academic high priests behave as if it is below their dignity to articulate their theories in a manner the common man (even an educated manager) can understand. Some of them seem to think that the world is made up of only rational economic agents analysing myriad decision variables in real-time leading to best possible outcome. Such elitism is still tolerable in music, literature, drama etc But in applied sciences like economics, management etc., unless it connects with the practitioners it will fail to have real value except to satisfy a few ego trips
If they don’t find a way to reach across to the guy who is expected to practice the theories they propound, how can they expect those thoughts to be more widely accepted? If they don’t find a way to fathom the life and challenges of the practitioners, how can they evolve solutions that are acceptable? If they don’t understand the inner fears, insecurities and private agendas and work around them, how can they implement policies that are game changers?
On the other hand the managers and administrators hide their laziness to be up-to-date and unwillingness to think-through, under their complaints on impracticability of the academic thoughts. They are happy with the networking dinners, what the various vendors and interest groups are keen to convince them or their boss’s whims. The more ‘professional manager’ or the more senior in the bureaucratic ladder they are, the more intransigent and intellectually sterile they make themselves. Quick results at whatever cost instead of institution building become the norm than an exception.
Our educational institutions, even the elite ones, fail to bridge this chasm to any meaningful extent. Our schools focus primarily on the ability to memorise and regurgitate answers to a bank of potential questions that may come for the exams. The colleges follow the same route too and the kids forget everything the moment the exams are over because the focus is more on marks than on what is learned. We can’t blame them as none of the teachings are contextual and most fail to demonstrate any relevance. Then the schools and colleges become just tools to attain a degree which itself is nothing but a pre-requisite to open many doors.
My blog is my attempt to address this conflict within me; the conflict between practical compulsions and theoretical possibilities. The blog for me is not a log of my private life laid bare to the public voyeurism as a means of keeping in touch. It is a tool that forces me to work on a thought and think-through its nuances for a few hours; crossing the ‘t’s and dotting the ‘i’s, which helps to bring some more clarity in my mind. It also throws open, to peer scrutiny, criticism and appreciation, my interpretations and how I use this learning (or the lack of it) and interpretations in tackling day-to-day challenges.
When I get your comments or thoughts or experiences on related issues, (I get many private mails in response to my postings and it appears that many are not comfortable to take a public position, may be eventually they will) it could offer another avenue,for both of us, to benefit from the “wisdom of the crowds” at very little cost. Some academicians willing to skim through these ramblings may also get some ideas on how to “win and influence” the guys in the trenches.
The illiterate of the 21st century will not be those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn, and relearn. ALVIN TOFFLER
Monday, April 5, 2010
It doesn’t make sense
The newspapers these days have almost a daily coverage on Sania Mirza’s marriage to Shoaib Mallik, the Pakistan cricketer. It is a celebrity wedding and there is controversy; so newspapers have a right to capitalise on this. It is a matter of circulation and profits for them.
Why should there be such controversy? Isn’t it their personal choice 'whom to marry'? The controversy is because she is marrying a Pakistani and anything related to Pakistan is paranoia these days. (The feelings are mutual)
I remember an incident that was narrated by one of my friends narrated. He is the country head of a multinational IT firm in India. He had a technical expert coming over for a project and he was by roots a Pakistani though he has never been to Pakistan as his father had migrated to US. It took an enormous effort to get the visa cleared. Then the local police insisted that he could not move out of the hotel room, except to attend office. They posted two police men outside his hotel room. This young lad had to be in this state of house (hotel) arrest for almost a month. Almost at the end of his project, he decided to go for a picnic with his friends for a drive out.
He sent an SMS to the local Police Superintend as he could not get him on phone. Within an hour the matter became a security emergency and quite a lot of harassment to his local sponsors and him. He had to be packed out of the country within a day!
It is true that both countries are not on good terms and forces of destabilisation are at work everywhere. We agree that we need to be careful that 26/11 is not repeated.
But does it mean that we have to have these extreme reaction in anything related with Pakistan and vice versa? There is no reason why Sania is not allowed a visa to visit the hometown of her would be fiancé and there was no sense it kicking up the controversy on the participation of Pakistani Cricketers in IPL.
Doesn’t it make sense to keep the tension low and encourage better interaction between both the countries without dilution of security controls? For example we have very strict verification process when we issue a passport. But, on the basis of the standing of the person (which is clearly defined and traceable) who issues a testimony there is of course a relaxation.
This is not an exception based on nepotism but an exceptional process of risk mitigation. If we find that such exceptional process can help more avenues for healthy interaction and such exceptions don't affect security concerns, we should try to encourage it. This can only help to strengthen both the countries.
Let us also ask ourselves some hard questions on the underlying causes of this mutual distrust. Don’t factors like religious intolerance, political expediency, attempt to distract public attention, machinations of a variety of interest groups and the self interest of the arms lobby contribute to this sustained tension?
Some of us need to rise above these biases, to build up a voice of reason, a voice of tolerance and a voice of compromise if we have to see a de-escalation of tension at the border and deep in our hearts. May be we need a few more marriages like that of Sania and Shoaib, some more train rides like the one Vajpayee initiated and a lot more cricket. The idea is to allow more opportunities for active engagement and more occasions to come together as human beings; sharing joy and sorrow. It is then that we can bring about disarmament of minds. But it is worth it.
“Unless both sides win, no agreement can be permanent.” ~ Jimmy Carter
Why should there be such controversy? Isn’t it their personal choice 'whom to marry'? The controversy is because she is marrying a Pakistani and anything related to Pakistan is paranoia these days. (The feelings are mutual)
I remember an incident that was narrated by one of my friends narrated. He is the country head of a multinational IT firm in India. He had a technical expert coming over for a project and he was by roots a Pakistani though he has never been to Pakistan as his father had migrated to US. It took an enormous effort to get the visa cleared. Then the local police insisted that he could not move out of the hotel room, except to attend office. They posted two police men outside his hotel room. This young lad had to be in this state of house (hotel) arrest for almost a month. Almost at the end of his project, he decided to go for a picnic with his friends for a drive out.
He sent an SMS to the local Police Superintend as he could not get him on phone. Within an hour the matter became a security emergency and quite a lot of harassment to his local sponsors and him. He had to be packed out of the country within a day!
It is true that both countries are not on good terms and forces of destabilisation are at work everywhere. We agree that we need to be careful that 26/11 is not repeated.
But does it mean that we have to have these extreme reaction in anything related with Pakistan and vice versa? There is no reason why Sania is not allowed a visa to visit the hometown of her would be fiancé and there was no sense it kicking up the controversy on the participation of Pakistani Cricketers in IPL.
Doesn’t it make sense to keep the tension low and encourage better interaction between both the countries without dilution of security controls? For example we have very strict verification process when we issue a passport. But, on the basis of the standing of the person (which is clearly defined and traceable) who issues a testimony there is of course a relaxation.
This is not an exception based on nepotism but an exceptional process of risk mitigation. If we find that such exceptional process can help more avenues for healthy interaction and such exceptions don't affect security concerns, we should try to encourage it. This can only help to strengthen both the countries.
Let us also ask ourselves some hard questions on the underlying causes of this mutual distrust. Don’t factors like religious intolerance, political expediency, attempt to distract public attention, machinations of a variety of interest groups and the self interest of the arms lobby contribute to this sustained tension?
Some of us need to rise above these biases, to build up a voice of reason, a voice of tolerance and a voice of compromise if we have to see a de-escalation of tension at the border and deep in our hearts. May be we need a few more marriages like that of Sania and Shoaib, some more train rides like the one Vajpayee initiated and a lot more cricket. The idea is to allow more opportunities for active engagement and more occasions to come together as human beings; sharing joy and sorrow. It is then that we can bring about disarmament of minds. But it is worth it.
“Unless both sides win, no agreement can be permanent.” ~ Jimmy Carter
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)