Pages

Showing posts with label Management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Management. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 12, 2026

THE UPSIDE WITHIN

 


The morning we launched NSDL, the newspaper called it “a new era for Indian investors.”

I kept that line in my head in the coming days as the purpose of our existence. Because for almost a year, that was all we had. The headline said new era. The ledger said single digits.

Not thousands of accounts. Not hundreds. Single digits, against a country of investors we were supposed to be opening this for.

And every few weeks the phone would ring, from the press, from the markets. “How many today?” And I would give a number you could count on one hand.

Then the same newspapers that had written “new era” printed the verdict. “A costly experiment that isn’t working.” Change the model. It has failed.

I was not the man in charge, I was young, and a part of the founding team. But when you read your project’s obituary in the same paper that announced its birth, seniority doesn’t protect you. It felt like mine.

And I had the choice a lot of you either have had or are going to have. Walk away from something the world has already buried or don’t.

Now you’re waiting for the grit speech. I pushed harder, I never gave up, believe in yourself.

That would be a lie. It wasn’t grit. Grit often is just fear with its teeth clenched, and fear cannot build anything new, a mind in panic can only defend, it cannot imagine.

What got us through was quieter. Two things that our MD and mentor Mr Bhave instilled in us. A sense of gratitude to steady the mind, a grip on what was still standing, even at single digits. And a purpose to point it, a reason worth the year.

Steady, and aimed. That combination will attempt almost anything. We just didn’t have the words for it yet. We only had the account that wouldn’t open, and a reason I couldn’t let go of.

Here’s the thing nobody warns you about hard problems. There’s a kind where you know the problem and you know the answer, you just do the work. There’s a harder kind where you know the problem but not the answer. And then there’s the last kind, where you don’t know the problem and you don’t know the answer. You set out with nothing but the shape of a dream in the dark.

That’s where the depository lived. That’s where anything worth building lives. Not with a plan, with a shape, and the nerve to walk toward it.

There’s an old story. A mouse complains to a lion his life is too dangerous. “Simple,” says the lion. “Become as big as me.” “But how?” asks the mouse. “That’s your problem,” says the lion. “I’m the king. I only make policy.”

Most grand visions are that lion. A magnificent goal, and none of the weight of how. A real purpose is the opposite; it’s a dream you agree to carry the how for. That’s the whole difference between a leader and a slogan.

Picture a metro station that’s been spotless for years. Not one wrapper. Not one mark on the wall. And notice what that does to you, you’d feel ashamed to be the one who drops the first thing.

Now picture one cigarette butt in the corner. Just one. And something in you shifts. Now one more won’t matter. And if there are already ten thousand complaints no one has answered, what harm can one more do?

That’s how a station falls apart. That’s how an institution falls apart. And that’s how a person falls apart. Never in one collapse, always one small permission at a time.

So the hardest discipline of that whole year wasn’t heroic. It was an account that everyone said wasn’t worth chasing. And chasing it anyway. Because the day you stop caring about the one, you’ve already started to fall.

Years later I was asked to build something much larger. An open network, so the smallest shopkeeper in the country could reach a buyer anywhere, without belonging to anyone’s walled garden.

And early on, it came back. The doubt. The “this will never work.” The pressure to quietly change the model. The same cold feeling I’d had years before, alone, at single digits.

But this time I recognised it. I knew exactly what state I was in, and I knew it was lying to me. The steadiness I’d stumbled into by accident the first time, I could now find on purpose.

Same two things. Bigger stage. I won’t walk you through what got built. What matters today is only this, it was portable. Whatever carried a frightened young man through one project carried a national idea through the next. It travelled with me.

And then it did something I didn’t expect. It left.

The idea travelled to another country. There’s an Indonesia Open Network now, and I’m part of it, but not as the founder, and not as the man in charge. As a mentor. My entire job is to help a local team learn from our idea, and our mistakes, and then to make sure they own it, and they deliver it.

Think about what that proves. If this had really been mine, my brilliance, my achievement, it couldn’t move. It would still need me. The fact that it’s growing in Jakarta, in hands that aren’t mine, in a language I don’t speak, that’s the proof it was never mine to begin with.

The idea was never in me. It was in the idea. And the idea only proved its upside the moment it stopped needing me.

So, that headline. “A new era for Indian investors.” It turned out it was never really about investors, or accounts, or a model that worked.

It was a test of what was inside, whether there was something under the failure steady enough, and aimed enough, to chase one stuck account through almost a year of obituaries.

Every one of you is carrying something right now that looks, from the outside, like the odds are against it. And you’ve been told the upside is out there, in a better year, more money, an easier hand.

It isn’t out there. It never was.

And you’ll know it was real not when it makes you look big, but when it outgrows you. When you can put it in someone else’s hands, step back, and watch it stand without you.

That’s the upside within. It was never meant to stay inside you.


Thursday, May 28, 2026

AI, Costs, and the Myth of Inevitable Human Obsolescence

 

 



Why the disruption narrative is more complicated, and more hopeful, than it appears

For years, the AI narrative has been relentlessly linear and tinged with apocalypse: models get smarter, cheaper, and more capable, and humans get edged aside, role by role, sector by sector. Then came a headline that disrupted the script.

“Microsoft is limiting internal use of expensive AI coding tools as enterprise AI costs surge.”

It sounded like a contradiction from the company that bet its future on AI, poured $80 billion into data centres, and plastered Copilot across every product it makes. It was not a contradiction. It was a revelation, though, as we shall see, a more layered one than the headline suggests.

The Economics Behind the Curtain

Inside Microsoft’s engineering divisions, Claude Code, the AI coding assistant from Anthropic, was not cancelled because it failed. It was cancelled because it succeeded too well. Rolled out to roughly 5,000 engineers in the division behind Windows, Microsoft 365, Outlook, Teams and Surface, it reached usage rates of 84 to 95 percent within months. Engineers used it relentlessly, and token-based billing, where every prompt, every agentic loop, every code-generation cycle costs real money, ran to an estimated $500 to $2,000 per engineer per month. The internal memo set a cancellation deadline of June 30, 2026.

The pattern is wider than Microsoft. Uber’s CTO has confirmed the company burned through its entire planned 2026 AI coding budget in four months, after actively incentivising engineers to maximise usage. Meta built an internal leaderboard called “Claudeonomics” to track which employees were consuming the most AI tokens. Amazon encouraged “tokenmaxxing”, gamifying maximum AI consumption as a proxy for productivity.

Two honest caveats belong in this story, and most commentary has skipped both.

First, Microsoft’s decision was not purely about cost. Engineers reportedly preferred Anthropic’s tool to Microsoft’s own Copilot CLI, and the cancellation conveniently redirects them into Microsoft’s own stack. Cost was real; so was competitive strategy. Second, the escape route is no escape: GitHub Copilot itself is moving to usage-based billing from June 2026. The token meter is not a Claude problem. It is the emerging price structure of frontier AI itself.

The collective result stands nonetheless: for many enterprise tasks today, undisciplined AI usage is more expensive than the humans it was meant to augment. The promise was frictionless efficiency. The reality is that when thousands of employees use frontier models without governance, the economics invert.

The Objection This Argument Must Survive

Before drawing conclusions, the cost story has to face its strongest counter-argument: the price of intelligence is falling, fast. The cost of frontier-quality inference has been dropping several-fold every year. What looks like a “cost ceiling” in 2026 could look like a rounding error by 2028. So is the Microsoft episode just a temporary blip?

Not quite, and the reason is an old one. Economists call it the Jevons effect: when something useful gets cheaper, we do not spend less on it; we use vastly more of it. Microsoft’s engineers did not hit a budget wall because tokens are expensive. They hit it because usage exploded faster than prices fell, agentic loops, always-on assistants, code generated and regenerated at industrial scale. Every cost decline to date has been swallowed by appetite. The lesson is not that AI is permanently expensive. The lesson is that AI consumption, like cloud computing before it, will always expand to consume the budget available, and therefore governance of usage, not the price of tokens, is the durable management problem.

Does This Slow the Replacement of Humans?

Only partially, and only temporarily. The cost ceiling buys time. It does not change direction.

The “AI will replace humans” narrative was always too blunt. AI is not a flat substitute for human labour. It has a cost curve. At low usage it is remarkable. At scale, without discipline, it is ruinous. Companies will not replace human beings wholesale. They will replace them selectively, deploying AI where ROI is unambiguous, retaining humans where judgment, accountability, ambiguity, or trust cannot be priced away.

The most exposed roles are not at the bottom of the skills ladder or the top. They are in the middle: paralegals, junior coders, financial analysts, content writers, customer service agents, roles that are routine, pattern-based, and high-volume. At Uber, around 70 percent of committed code now originates with AI. That number should concentrate the mind of every mid-career professional whose work is pattern recognition at volume.

The Radiology Test: Why “Exposed” Is the Wrong Word

But “exposed” is a one-dimensional lens, and one profession shows why. Consider radiology, the example most often cited, for a decade now, as the first white-collar casualty of AI.

On capability, the pessimists are right: AI can read many scans as well as or better than humans, and the per-unit economics are unanswerable. On accountability, the pessimists are early: in most jurisdictions, a diagnosis requires a licensed human signature, and regulators, courts and insurers will keep it that way for some time, not because the human is always more accurate, but because someone must be answerable when the machine is wrong.

And on access, the pessimists have the sign of the effect backwards, at least in a country like India. The binding constraint on radiology in small-town and rural India has never been an oversupply of radiologists. It is that there are almost none. AI-assisted reading changes that arithmetic. A local physician in a taluk hospital, supported by AI triage and a remote human radiologist for sign-off, can now order and act on imaging that was previously out of reach. The realistic effect in such markets is not fewer radiology jobs but more radiology, more referrals, more scans, more diagnostic activity, and new paramedical and technician roles around it, in places where the alternative was not a human radiologist but nothing at all.

The same technology, in the same year, can displace work in saturated markets and create it in underserved ones. Radiology is not an exception; it is the template. Apply the same three questions, can AI do it, who must answer for it, and where was the service never available at all, to law, to accounting, to software, to education, and the picture that emerges is not a single wave of obsolescence but a redistribution: of tasks within professions, and of services across geographies.

The Real Disruptor: Robotics, Not Software

While enterprises wrestle with token bills, robotics companies are solving a different equation. A humanoid robot is largely a capital expenditure: its “salary” is electricity, maintenance and software. Tesla Optimus, Figure and Boston Dynamics are targeting price points intended to undercut the minimum wage in developed economies within this decade, beginning with exactly the jobs that employ hundreds of millions globally, fast food, warehouse picking, hotel housekeeping, retail stocking.

Two qualifications keep this honest. First, the cost structure is different from software AI, not free of recurring costs: many robotics firms are pricing robots-as-a-service, with subscriptions and teleoperation support, a cousin of the token meter, not its opposite. Second, the crossover point depends on the wage it must undercut. A robot that beats a $15-an-hour wage in Ohio is nowhere near beating a ₹15,000-a-month wage in Kanpur. Which leads to a striking inversion: the Global South will likely adopt software AI fastest, because models are cheap and skilled labour is scarce, and adopt robotics slowest, because physical labour is abundant and cheap. The displacement map of the next decade will not be uniform. It will be a patchwork drawn by local wages.

The China Factor: The Cost Floor May Collapse

DeepSeek’s breakthrough in early 2025, and the rapid succession of low-cost Chinese models since, changed the global cost equation in ways that have not been fully absorbed. Frontier-level reasoning delivered at a fraction of Western pricing, backed by structural advantages: subsidised compute and energy, lower infrastructure costs, and less shareholder pressure to monetise quickly.

If such models gain wide adoption across India, Southeast Asia, Latin America and Africa, markets where price matters more than geopolitics, the cost barrier falls years ahead of current projections. And note that this cuts both ways: cheap models accelerate displacement of routine work, but they equally accelerate the access story told above. The same collapsing cost floor that threatens the call-centre agent makes the AI-assisted rural clinic viable. The West will move more cautiously, constrained by data sovereignty and regulatory anxiety. The Global South may move faster, precisely because it cannot afford to be slow.

This creates a two-speed world of AI adoption, and, by extension, a two-speed world of both displacement and inclusion. That asymmetry deserves far more attention than it receives in the global policy conversation, which remains written almost entirely from the vantage point of high-wage economies.

The Jobs That Don’t Exist Yet

Every major technological shift destroys familiar work and creates categories of work invisible until they become indispensable. The steam engine did not just displace handloom weavers; it created railway engineers and factory inspectors. The internet did not merely kill travel agencies; it created cloud architects and UX designers. The honest difficulty is that new jobs are not legible until they exist.

Still, the outlines are forming at the margins: people who design how humans and AI divide work and supervise each other; specialists who generate and govern synthetic data as real data becomes regulated and scarce; professionals who arbitrate between AI outputs and human decisions in finance, healthcare and law; a new blue-collar profession maintaining and supervising robot fleets; AI safety and governance analysts, a field that will grow to the scale of cybersecurity; and millions of AI-enabled one-person enterprises that would have been operationally impossible a decade ago. Above all, as AI absorbs the burden of logic and pattern, the premium on trust, empathy, cultural context and meaning rises, precisely because AI cannot credibly supply them.

AI as an Equaliser: The Welfare Dimension

If AI dramatically reduces the cost of delivering essential services, the welfare gains could, under the right policy conditions, outweigh the disruption to employment. AI-optimised irrigation and supply-chain prediction could raise yields and cut food waste across the Global South. AI triage, diagnostic support and remote monitoring could bring quality care to populations who currently have none, the radiology story above, repeated across a dozen specialities. Adaptive AI tutors could personalise learning for hundreds of millions of children for whom quality schooling remains a geographic accident of birth.

If AI reduces the cost of food, health and education by half or more, the question is no longer simply “who loses their job?” It becomes “what kind of society do we build with the surplus?” That is a question of political will, not technology.

Where Humans Still Win on ROI

Despite the compression of timelines, some domains will remain higher-ROI for humans through this decade: trust-based, relationship-driven work, where clients pay a premium for human accountability; novel problem-solving in genuinely ambiguous environments, where no training data exists for the situation at hand; skilled trades in unstructured physical settings, the plumber navigating an unfamiliar home, the electrician improvising under deadline; and regulated roles where law or professional standards mandate human sign-off regardless of AI capability.

The pattern across these safe harbours is consistent. What makes humans irreplaceable is not intelligence alone. It is accountability, physical adaptability, and the fact that in some relationships the human presence is the product, not merely the mechanism of its delivery.

The Question That Actually Matters

The debate has moved on from whether AI will displace human workers. The debate now is: which humans, doing which tasks, in which geographies, on what timeline, under which cost structures, and, critically, will the new categories of work emerge quickly enough, and be accessible enough, to absorb those displaced?

The cost ceiling revealed by Microsoft, Uber and others is real. It slows the slope, forces selectivity, and creates space for societies to adapt rather than absorb a vertical shock. But it does not alter the destination. The direction of travel has not changed, only the gradient of the curve. And the gradient, as the radiology test shows, points in different directions in different places: downward for routine work in saturated markets, upward for services in markets that never had them.

The most important investment any individual, institution, or government can make right now is not in AI itself. It is in the human capacity to navigate the transition: to identify which skills will compound in value, which roles are building toward the new categories, and which paths are quietly narrowing.

“AI will not erase human value. It will redraw the map of where that value lives, and whether we prepare to inhabit that new terrain is the defining challenge of this decade.”

Sources: The Verge (Tom Warren, Notepad, May 14, 2026) on Microsoft’s internal Claude Code cancellation; The Information (April 2026) on Uber’s AI coding budget; Fortune (May 22, 2026) on Meta’s “Claudeonomics” and Amazon’s token incentives.


Friday, May 8, 2026

E = MC² : The Equation That Never Gets Old


 

On Measurement, Continuous Improvement, and Customer Focus — Then and Now

 (A decade and half ago I wrote two linked blogs on Operational Excellence. They are referred at the bottom of this article. When I read them in the context of the world of today, many principles remail the same, but manifestations are different. This article is an attempt to revisit the idea of Operational Excellence in the era of AI and Agents)

There is a particular kind of excitement that technology companies are exceptionally good at, and a particular kind of discipline they are chronically bad at. The excitement is building. The discipline is running. Every new feature, every new product, every new platform gets showered with energy, talent, and attention. The unglamorous work of making sure it all actually works, consistently, reliably, at scale, day after day, gets left to whoever is available, measured by whatever is easy to measure, and improved only when something breaks badly enough to be embarrassing.

This is not a new observation. But it has become a vastly more consequential one. Because we are now deploying AI systems and autonomous agents into operational environments at a pace that far outstrips our willingness, or our ability, to govern them. And the cost of that gap is no longer measured in minor inefficiencies. It is measured in compounding, invisible failures,  in decisions that are wrong by design, in resources consumed by systems nobody is watching, and in customers quietly harmed by processes nobody is truly accountable for.

The answer to this is not more technology. It is better operational discipline. And the framework for that discipline is simpler than most people think.

We call it E = MC²: Excellence, derived from a culture that Measures relentlessly, pursues Continuous improvement, and never loses sight of Customer focus. These three elements are not independent. They are a virtuous cycle, each one feeding the others, each one incomplete without the others. Understanding how they connect, and how to make them real, is the central challenge of operational management in any era. Including this one.

Why Measurement is Hard, Even for People Who Handle Data for a Living

There is a paradox at the heart of the IT and services industries. These are sectors whose entire value proposition rests on data, on capturing it, organising it, analysing it, and making it useful. And yet, in practice, their internal operational measurement discipline is often surprisingly immature. The processes that organisations build for their customers are rarely applied with equal rigour to their own operations.

The reasons are not mysterious. The glamour in these industries flows toward novelty, toward "cool functions," "exciting features," and "latest gadgets." Boring pursuit of efficiency gains simply does not compete for talent or attention. When a senior engineer has a choice between building something new and spending six weeks instrumenting something old to understand why it sometimes fails, the outcome is predictable. And so operational measurement tends to happen reactively,  in response to a crisis, a customer complaint, or a regulator's inquiry,  rather than as a continuous, proactive discipline.

To learn how to do this differently, it helps to look at industries that never had the luxury of treating operations as an afterthought.

The hazardous chemical process industry is an instructive model, and not an intuitive one. It has been around for centuries, long enough to have matured its operational practices through hard experience. Its product lines are largely commoditised, which means margins are thin and efficiency is not optional, It is existential. The consequences of process failures are sometimes fatal, which means the scrutiny.  public, regulatory, and internal, is unrelenting. And its processes are integrated end-to-end, with limited visibility into what is actually happening inside the pipes at any given moment, which forces a culture of strong monitoring and control.

These are, in fact, exactly the conditions that characterise complex digital operations today. Thin margins. High stakes. Limited internal visibility. Regulatory scrutiny. The main difference is that the chemical industry has spent decades building the measurement culture to match these conditions, while the technology and services industries are still, in many cases, at the beginning of that journey.

From that more mature tradition, three elements of measurement discipline emerge as foundational.

The Three Pillars of Measurement

Flow Management: Count Every Transaction

The first pillar is what might be called micromanagement of the operation, not in the pejorative sense of hovering over people, but in the precise sense of tracking each input through each sub-process it was meant to traverse, confirming it arrived correctly and without error.

This sounds obvious. In practice, it is done poorly, or not at all, especially for processes that are still evolving. When a new system or workflow is still being refined, exceptions proliferate. And exceptions, in young computerised systems, have a dangerous tendency to become invisible,  swallowed by automated retry mechanisms, silently skipped, or classified as edge cases that never quite make it onto anyone's priority list.

The consequences of poor flow management are almost always financial and reputational, and they tend to be discovered embarrassingly late. A large bank once sent letters to its credit card customers admitting that it had not been tracking transactions correctly, and asking recipients to settle on the basis of their own personal records. The transactions were not hidden. They were not stolen. They had simply not been tracked. The systems were running; the accounting was not. When providers of transaction billing solutions are brought into organisations for the first time, the revenue leakage they surface, from transactions that fell through the cracks of inadequately monitored processes, is routinely staggering.

These are not exotic failures. They are the entirely predictable consequence of building systems without building the measurement infrastructure to watch over them.

Capacity Management: Know Where the Bottlenecks Are Before They Happen

The second pillar is the macro view, tracking the capacity of processes, people, service providers, and machines in order to anticipate bottlenecks before they become crises. This requires establishing trend measures for each element and monitoring them continuously, not just periodically.

Capacity management is especially treacherous in computerised environments for a structural reason: shared resources. Network infrastructure, compute capacity, database connections,  these are all consumed by multiple processes simultaneously, and the utilisation curve for each process grows differently. A system that appears to have adequate capacity for today's workload may have none for tomorrow's if the growth curves are not being watched and modelled.

Two particular categories of hidden capacity consumers deserve special attention, because they are pervasive and almost universally underestimated.

The first is queries. Every business generates a need for data extracts — for management reporting, regulatory compliance, customer service lookups, and ad hoc analysis. These queries consume the same production capacity as the operational processes. And they are disproportionately likely to be written inefficiently, because they are typically assigned to junior resources or business analysts who lack the training to optimise them, and because there is very little accountability for query performance until something breaks. A query that was meant to run once becomes a standard report. A standard report that runs nightly becomes a standard report that runs hourly. The cumulative resource consumption creeps upward invisibly until, one day, the system slows to a crawl during peak operational hours, and nobody can immediately explain why.

The second is design debt. For most software developers, the genuine satisfaction is in building features. Once a feature is live and functioning, interest moves on. The pressure to optimise, to refactor, to improve efficiency, runs directly against the incentive to ship the next thing. The result is that bespoke systems accumulate performance inefficiencies that are never addressed , not because fixing them is technically difficult, but because nobody is measuring the cost of leaving them in place, and nobody is accountable for the cumulative drag. In most organisations, there is scope for at least a hundred percent improvement in process efficiency simply by addressing the worst of these design inefficiencies,  but only if someone is measuring for them.

Service Levels: Commit to the Customer, Then Track the Commitment

The third pillar is where measurement connects most directly to purpose. The most powerful mechanism for ensuring that measurement and improvement activity stays focused and meaningful is to define, publicly and clearly, what the organisation is actually committing to deliver to its customers.

There is an important distinction to draw here between a Service Level Agreement and what might be called a Customer Service Commitment. An SLA is a floor — a formal definition of the minimum below which the organisation will try not to fall. It is a legal and contractual instrument, and it tends to create a culture of adequacy: as long as we are above the floor, we are fine. A Customer Service Commitment is something different. It is a genuine aspiration — a statement of what the organisation sincerely believes it can and should deliver, at a level meaningfully above the minimum.

This distinction matters because people and systems tend to optimise for what they are measured against. An organisation that measures against its SLAs will manage its operations to the SLA threshold. An organisation that measures against its Customer Service Commitments will manage its operations to the standard it actually believes in.

The mechanics of tracking these commitments deserve specific attention. Time-series data, tracking key performance parameters not just at a point in time, but continuously over time. is essential for detecting trends before they become crises. A single data point t ells you where you are today. A trend tells you where you are going. And it is the trend that matters operationally, because by the time a single bad reading turns into an obvious crisis, the window for preventive action has usually closed.

It is also worth having the team that tracks customer commitments sit separately from the team responsible for operations. This is not about distrust. It is about the structural reality that an operations team under pressure will, understandably, interpret ambiguous data in the most favourable light available. A separate tracking function provides the independent visibility that makes measurement honest.

Continuous Improvement: From Counting to Acting

All of this measurement serves one purpose: enabling the organisation to improve, continuously, before it is forced to by failure.

This is more difficult than it sounds, because the culture required to use data for continuous improvement is fundamentally different from the culture most organisations actually have. In most places, data tracking reports are either compliance artifacts — produced to satisfy an audit or a boss, or post-mortem instruments, pulled out after something has gone wrong to explain what happened. Neither of these uses generates improvement. They generate paper trails.

The culture of continuous improvement requires something harder: the regular, disciplined use of data to find problems that have not yet caused visible failures. This means looking at trend shifts before they become obvious. It means investigating unusual volatility in metrics that are still technically within acceptable bounds. It means preferring prevention over heroism — which runs directly against the organisational instinct that rewards the person who fixed the crisis rather than the person who avoided it.

To make this a habit rather than an occasional initiative, it has to become a ritual. The cadence of reviewing operational data, identifying trends, assigning root cause investigations, and tracking improvement actions has to be embedded into the organisation's regular rhythm, not treated as an additional burden on top of "real work." When it is done well, it does not feel like overhead. It feels like the organisation learning from itself in real time.

The AI Era Changes the Stakes, Not the Principles

Everything described above was relevant in 2009. It is more relevant now by an order of magnitude.

The introduction of AI systems and autonomous agents into operational environments does not render these principles obsolete. It makes them urgent. Because AI introduces a new category of operational actor, one that is more capable, more opaque, and more consequential than anything that preceded it,  into environments that, in many cases, barely had adequate measurement cultures to begin with.

The most important thing to understand about AI in operations is that it fails in ways that are qualitatively different from how conventional software fails. Traditional software fails visibly. A system crashes. A transaction errors out. A service goes down. These failures are, in their own way, manageable, because they announce themselves. AI fails silently. A model that has drifted from its training data continues to generate outputs that look confident and coherent, while producing decisions that are subtly, systematically wrong. A recommendation engine with a bias baked into its training data does not flag an anomaly; it just consistently disadvantages certain customers. A document processing agent that hallucinates does not throw an exception; it produces a confident, plausible, and incorrect result.

This is the flow management problem, rewritten for the age of AI. Every AI-powered process needs a systematic accounting not just of what it produces, but of the quality, reliability, and drift of those outputs over time. The input went in; the output came out, but was the agent's reasoning within acceptable bounds? Was its confidence calibrated? Were there exceptions that the system silently swallowed rather than escalating to a human? The revenue leakage and customer harm that flow from unmonitored AI processes make the untracked credit card transactions of an earlier era look quaint.

The capacity management problem is also fundamentally transformed. AI models are the most resource-intensive entities ever introduced into enterprise operations. A single large model inference can consume more compute than an entire legacy application stack, and when multiple agents run concurrently, as they increasingly do, in agentic architectures where AI systems orchestrate other AI systems, the shared infrastructure constraints become genuinely complex to manage. The hidden capacity consumers have multiplied: poorly designed prompts that generate verbose, expensive outputs; inefficient agent chains that make redundant calls; one-time AI automations that quietly become permanent fixtures eating into rate limits and GPU capacity. None of this shows up on a standard IT dashboard unless someone has specifically built the instrumentation to see it.

And the service levels question, always the most important one, has become the most morally loaded. When an AI agent makes a decision that affects a customer,  about a loan, a medical triage, a service entitlement, a pricing offer,  that customer has a right to understand it, challenge it, and have a human correct it. This is not only a regulatory requirement in an increasing number of jurisdictions. It is the operational definition of customer focus in a world where the agent, not the employee, is the primary interface. A Customer Service Commitment in the AI era must include commitments about explainability, human override, and recoverability, not just turnaround time and accuracy.

The Measurement Culture the AI Era Demands

Bringing this together, what does operational excellence actually look like for an organisation running AI at scale?

It looks like flow management that tracks not just whether transactions were processed, but whether the AI agents that touched those transactions acted within defined parameters, and that surfaces exceptions rather than silently absorbing them.

It looks like capacity management that instruments AI resource consumption with the same rigour that a hazardous chemical plant instruments its pressures and temperatures,  understanding not just current utilisation, but growth trajectories, shared resource constraints, and the hidden consumers that creep up over time.

It looks like Customer Service Commitments that extend into the AI layer,  that define not just what will be delivered, but how decisions will be explained, how errors will be corrected, and how human accountability will be maintained even where AI is the primary actor.

And it looks like an organisation where data is used not to satisfy bosses or produce compliance artifacts, but as a genuine tool for continuous improvement by everyone at every level. Where a shift in a trend line is treated as a signal worth investigating, not as noise to be explained away. Where prevention is valued as much as heroism. Where the excitement of building is matched, at last, by the discipline of running.

The Hardest Part Has Not Changed

In the end, the measurement framework, however well designed, is only as good as the culture that uses it. And culture is stubbornly human. The data is the easy part. The hard part is persuading organisations and the people within them to use data as a tool for honest self-improvement rather than as a performance to be staged for external audiences.

That challenge has not changed in sixteen years. It will not change in the next sixteen either. What changes is the cost of getting it wrong.

Give the people the facts, about their processes, their agents, their customers, their capacity, their failures, and their potential,  and they will, if the culture is right, do the right thing.

That is still the bet. It is a harder bet to lose than it has ever been. But it is the only bet worth making.

"The customer does not care about your dashboard. They care about what happened to them. Those are not always the same thing."

Retaled Posts


Saturday, April 20, 2024

Who is your Mentor ?

 

Mentor is a person who can make a significant impact on your career or on your company, drawing on the expertise and experience that person has. Whom you choose as or who gets thrusted upon you to play a mentorship role can be a game changer for you.

It will be fun and also useful to be aware of the nuances with respect to mentor and mentorship to help you choose and benefit from mentors. The role of the mentor is not standard or same in all context. There are different roles that a mentor can play.

The mentor could bring superior subject matter expertise to help you to solve a problem or guide you through corporate web. For example, if you are trying raise funds for your new venture and if you have no prior experience in this, a mentor who may have had extensive exposure as a venture capitalist can be a great help in dealing with multiple service providers and to get the best possible deal. Or if you are considering organisation wide computerisation, someone who have lived through this transformation could help you to be ready for challenges on the way.

The mentor could offer references and endorsements with people of influence and relevance for your growth through his/her network. For example, when you are raising funds, some one who have dealt multiple investors and have had the experience to understand the agenda of the diverse players could help you to refine your investment pitch and may even give reference to different investors.

The mentor could be someone could act as a sounding board for your ideas and provide a philosophical foundation for your initiatives and decisions.  For example, someone who has had good experience in guiding organisational growth could help you in your process of developing alternate growth strategies, evaluating them and make a choice.

While a good mentor may be a mix of all, very often the larger focus may be in a few roles based on their comfort and your priorities.  A genuine mentor with appropriate experience and right intention can make a big difference to you and your company. They can add significant value in helping you to evolve strategies, guide your team, select better tools, turbocharge your marketing and magnify your public relation. Therefore. it will be great for any company to have a mentorship program established as it can contribute to its overall development through development and retention of good managers.

While we give due attention when working with a mentor there is another important dimension, we should be conscious of when choosing and or working with a mentor.

Ideally a mentor would be a person who has achieved certain stature and/ or position that he plays the role of a mentor as a giver and not a taker. Let us go a little deeper on the difference between giver and taker. The giver is a person who has more to give to the mentee. They are self-confident and will work with you to bring the best out of you and also not try to usurp the credit for your achievement, but help you to grow in your role. They will spent time to understand your context, the opportunities available, challenges you face, the strategies your following and proposing and identify your weaknesses and will give you considered advice. They will help you to track progress and act as a sounding board to help you to continuously refine your way forardy

The takers are those who act or pretend to act as your mentor, primarily to enhance their agenda. They will manage to make you doubt yourself and make it look like you are surviving on their ideas. The worst is when often they have nothing really to offer. They are too impatient to understand your context, your challenges, your option and their merits and weaknesses.  They will ask you about all your thoughts and make general comments and motherhood statements with no real value addition and at best may keep goading you to up your aspirations with no suggestions or input or support to make it happen. If you end up succeeding, they will go around announcing to the whole world that your success is courtesy their idea.

You have to be mindful of such people when you choose your mentors independent of their stature and position so that you don’t end up with the latter category. Very often they are in this position because they are better at managing their environment and more than willing to sell their souls for a price. For them end justifies the means with ‘end’ defined as maximising personal agenda. They are too happy to live off the hard work of the doers and smart in edging out the doers in due course like the pirates. (Read this post https://rollingstone-revelations.blogspot.com/2012/05/some-people-all-time-humour.html for a light hearted depiction of such mentors)

Sometimes they are thrusted upon you as advisors, or consultants or directors with you having no choice. Then you will have to have your strategy to protect you from them or manage them and may be the  support of another genuine mentor who will help you in your attempt for self-preservation.

C’est la vie!

“A mentor is someone who allows you to see the hope inside yourself.” Oprah Winfrey – Host, Producer, Author & Philanthropist

Sunday, August 17, 2014

Aadhaar or Not?


The total number of Aadhaar enrollment has reached a level of around 600 million. There are serious debates in the public domain about use of Aadhaar as mechanism to establish and verify identify for various subsidies and benefits extended to the residents of this country. Let us take a deep look at the merits and demerits of this idea.

Every entity that provides any benefit or service to a person has a need to establish the identity of the recipient at the time of enrollment into the scheme. It would also want to verify if the same person is receiving the benefit/ service every time the service is availed. For this purpose different entities use different methods and different supporting documents.  Aadhaar comes out as the best identity proof on account of the following.

·         Most of the identity documents that are commonly used like PAN card, Voter Id, passport, electricity bill and so on are only enrollment proof for a specific service. Therefore this limits the cross section of residents who can have each of these documents. This makes it essential for every service provider to allow a variety of identity document resulting in higher cost and risk. Aadhaar is issued by UIDAI which has been set up only for the purpose of issuing an identity documents to every resident. This makes it possible for every resident to receive an identity documents.

·         Aadhaar has established a centralised system and a standard process that is accessible throughout the country to verify the identity document submitted by the recipient of the service. This makes it easy for every service provider to establish uniform but strong verification mechanisms instead of establishing multiple verifications for various identity documents.  No other identity document has such a seamless verification process in place (many of them don’t give a facility to verify from the source if the identify document has been truly issued by the issuing entity) which makes it possible for the unscrupulous to get away with forged identity documents.

·         The above process also significantly reduces the cost and risk of identity verification.

Every service/ benefit provider could want to ensure that same person does not access the service under multiple identities. Aadhaar issues a unique number to a person supported by extremely strong biometric technology to ensure that one person cannot have multiple identities. The current practice of establishing uniqueness with demographic data like name, father’s name, age etc  is quite weak in comparison with this. No other identity document has such strong de-duplication mechanism in place to ensure that same person has multiple identities
.
The issuing authorities for the various documents used as proof of identity have established their channel for enrolment to meet their requirement and they do not cater to the need and right of every resident to receive an identity document. For example voter id is issued to eligible voters. PAN is a tax id and tax department has no incentive to extent this as a service to all residents. Since UIDAI is established as an entity to issue identify document, it has established extensive channel for issuance and verification and is in the process of further extending this channel.

This helps any entity which has to uniquely identify a person to save significant cost and effort in the identity verification process.  Building on this Axis bank now has introduced scheme wherein an individual can walk into any Axis Bank Branch, give his / her UID and after verification of the same, the banks issues an account without any further document.  Many service providers are figuring our innovative application of this idea. With more than 600 million cards already established we can soon witness wider adoption.

But let us be clear; only thing Aadhaar can guarantee is a unique identity, nothing else. Not citizenship, not right for any entitlement. For any of these you will need other mechanism. So we should judge and decide based on what Aadhaar can do and its relevance, and not what it cannot!


“No one  can stop an idea whose time has come” Victor Hugo

Monday, June 23, 2014

Making the Elephant Dance

We once had a government that tried to do everything by itself. In addition to the business of governance, it also actively dabbled in bread making to aircraft production and banking to hotels.  Over a period of time it has accepted that it should focus on its core responsibility of governance and has attempted to move out from non-core sectors. Therefore it has, in the recent past, started using private sector capital and private sector involvement to augment and strengthen governance and to provide public good

Some of these partnerships have been successes and some failures.  The success and failure of such joint initiatives depend on many factors.  The willingness of the key bureaucrats driving the project to take bold decisions and the scruples of the private sector partner are two critical factors of success.

The worst combination is when we have an indecisive officer and a scrupulous service provider. In this case the project will suffer and the service provider will suffer humongous loss. This is the reason why many private sector companies desist from working for government.

The next worst combination is when we have an officer who is decisive and absolutely corrupt teaming with an unscrupulous service provider. In this case they will clean the tills and the project will suffer.

The best result is when there is combination of decisive and result oriented officer and scrupulous service provider.  This is a road fraught with risks because this will involve judgement calls and judgement calls involve calculated risks based on information available at that point of time. But unfortunately these judgment calls often are often misinterpreted. This then leads to both parties being accused of the personal agenda behind their actions.  They get equated to the worst combination described above. Both end up suffering for the decisions they have taken. That is why this is a rare combination. However what we need today is this combination.  

This is less of an issue when outcomes of the envisaged projects are very clear and the scope of private sector participation can be articulated un-ambiguously. In these cases it will be possible to develop a clear contract and monitor the performance against the clear milestones in the contract. However in projects which are transformative in nature this becomes all the more critical. In this kind of project it will not be very easy to clearly develop the implementation plan and identify clear milestones. Therefore there will be many occasions, based on ground realities, when judgement calls are required to be made and course corrections are required to be effected. In such cases the combination of visionary and courageous leadership from the government and scruples of the service provider becomes very critical. 

In typical government procurement such a combination which will effectively enable active management will be very difficult to implement. This is the reason why many of the transformative projects in Private Public Participation fail.

This is especially true for IT projects. Today many top-notch IT companies are unwilling to work with government because they feel that government does not understand or appreciate this dimension. On account of this blindness on the part of the government buyer, for honest service providers government projects are loss leaders. Especially with the alternate business opportunities recovering around the world it will be difficult for the government to to attract good IT companies to take serious interest in the e-enablement of government projects.

The most effective way to handle such transformative projects is to carve these as independent projects and hand these over to a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) which has been suitably structured with sufficient flexibility to take nimble decisions and relevant mid-course corrections when needed. It is also important to have the right kind of leadership, team with relevant expertise and experience and also a supervisory body that recognizes the different approach needed for these SPVs to succeed. Especially the leadership vision and courage to take decisions will be very critical.  Delhi Metro is a very visible example of a successive implementation in this model.

There are many more transformative ideas that are awaiting such interventions especially in the area of digital transformation. We hope that the clear mandate the government has this time will help them take this path with more confidence. 




“Planning is helpful. If you don’t know what you want, you’ll seldom get it. But, no matter how well you plan, you will fare better if you expect the unexpected. The unexpected, by nature, comes unseen, unthought, unenvisioned. All you can do is plan to go unplanned, prepare to be unprepared, make going with the flow part of your agenda, for the most successful among us envision, plan, and prepare, but cast all aside as needed, while those who are unable to go with the flow often suffer, if they survive.”   David W. Jones, Moses and Mickey Mouse

If you liked this post, share it

Sunday, July 28, 2013

At What Cost


All of us will agree that Result orientation and Reliability are two critical attributes of a valuable executive in any organization. These are of as important as his/her domain knowledge. Most successful and sought after executives are very high in these two attributes.  Let us call these twin attributes R&R (not Rest and Recreation of the army variety.) Although we value those who are high on R&R there are cases when these essential attributes can turn out to be the poison within that contribute to organizational decay. Let us try to understand this a little more in detail. 

Result orientation describes how a person goes about executing his work, his logic of prioritization and his problem solving.  Result oriented people will focus on the outcome expected. They do not get bogged down by the constraints and difficulties. They also do not allow themselves to be caught up with procedural cobwebs. If there is a roadblock, they will find a work around. If there is a limitation they will find an alternative. If they are confronted with a procedural Gordian knot, they will find a sword to slice it away.

Reliability is highly correlated to result orientation. But it also has some different flavor. This also portrays how he relates to the members of the team and/or other stakeholders.  It is about how a person can be depended to do what is expected of him or what he has committed. When we ask a reliable person do something, you can be sure that he will give an honest feedback on if it can be done by him, and by when. Once he commits you don’t need to follow-up. If he is faced by a problem that he can’t solve, he will let you know in time. He will also give you an assessment of the impact of what is being executed among various stakeholders.

Some exhibit R&R in all/ most of their dealings. Some of them exhibit these qualities more to their subordinates. We can term this as downward orientation. They are those who look after their team. Such people can be sure to be bosses who are admired and adored. As they rise up to in their career they turn out to be leaders who can take their team along. But some time they fail to keep their bosses in good humor their growth may get stunted; especially if their bosses are insecure by nature.

Some exhibit it more to their colleagues. This can be termed as horizontal orientation. They are excellent peers you can have. They are normally very popular in the office and office parties.

Some others are resourceful and reliable for their bosses. They have upward orientation. They are bosses favorites. They are much clued onto what their bosses want. Especially they are alive to factors that irritate their bosses and they will find ways to solve them and they are alive to their bosses weaknesses. They become almost indispensable for their bosses.

But this last variety while they are excellent in what they do may end up being poison to their organizations; especially if they don’t have respect their colleagues and are not sensitive to their preferences and concerns. They may run roughshod with their colleagues and subordinates to give what their bosses want. When boss give a guideline of his preference, normally they expect the implementing person to assess and field reality and optimize the implementation plan. But purely upward oriented R&R completely disregard constraints/ concerns and aspirations of the team. They are almost  like bulldogs. Very often others will not complain to avoid being termed a whiner.  

We need to be very careful with such people. Because, silently they vitiate the environment they belong. Because they are very useful they become our favourites, we praise them too much because they deliver. If we are not alive to such insensitive behavior we may end up over promoting them. But this will breed resentment all around. This is specially the case with some people who work in the staff function like personnel, administration and finance. With very little responsibility in client facing activities where client satisfaction may get measured and significant control they have of day to day conveniences, upward orientation gives them enormous influence with the big bosses. They grow very fast. But this is cancerous growth. If it is not contained, it can spell doom for their organization in the long run. Unfortunately such behavior will have very negative impact on the bosses

I have met a few such people in my long career. One used to be an HR executive. She made sure that she implemented her boss’s wishes ruthlessly. She gave regular feedback to her boss on what is happening around. But she was an absolute failure as far as her role as an HR executive. Her colleagues could not stand her and her subordinates hated her. But she was the gunslinger for her bosses and hence their darling.

The worst is when they reach very senior position. That often becomes the beginning of the end for the organization they head. If they have risen up primarily by pleasing their bosses, they will have difficulty in making the team/ organization to deliver. But by then many of the good people would have left. With what is left, it could be practically difficult to deliver. That is why when we evaluate and reward performance of people it has to be against the total organizational cost (not the cost of salary and perks alone ) and not just on what they may deliver. Bull dogs can be good in hunting trips, but they can not be the one running the farm.

In the past a leader was a boss. Today's leaders must be partners with their people... they no longer can lead solely based on positional power.  Ken Blanchard



If you like this post, share it with your friends


Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Riding a Tiger

“It was like riding a tiger; not knowing how to get off without being eaten” This is how Raju, former chief of Satyam, described his cover up of the poor quarterly performance he started few years ago that grew to a multi-billion dollar accounting scam that finally engulfed him and his company.

I don’t claim to be privy to what happened nor do I know the complete details of the scam. But I don’t think that he is the only one who is into managing the books in some fashion to achieve or over achieve the targets. I am sure most of us would agree with me. May be he took it to the extreme; or maybe he just got caught?

See what happens when the year-end approaches. The extra effort and extra push to generate more sales is of course a great idea and desirable. But it doesn’t end there. Each industry has its own bag of tricks. Arm twist the distributer to take an extra consignment which he may not be able to sell in the coming quarter. An accommodating purchase manager could be asked to book an order which he can cancel in the next month. A conditional loan conformation from the client. Create a fictitious company to book an order that will one day be written off. This is not just a private sector phenomenon. Ask the tax-collector what tricks he has to reach the target. Anything goes for the sake of ‘numbers’; especially when the numbers lead to fat bonusus and or promotions. One of the primary reasons for the 2008 meltdown in financial markets was also this mad scramble.

The degree of accommodation may vary. Some will do a bit of arm twisting. Some will shift the next quarter sale to this quarter. (A short fall in the first quarter is understandable!) The degree of dishonesty varies from coercion to manipulation to absolute fraud. This is not just the handiwork of the sales manager. This is the culture we are inculcating and encouraging. This culture of deceit then becomes a part of the organisational DNA.Sometimes somebody gets carried away and goes all the way and occasionally a Raju gets caught. Just hard luck!

May be we should take the spirit of the “General Anti-Avoidance Rules” in taxation where admissibility of an item of expenditure is supposed to be based on whether it is a truly value adding transaction or a transaction just for the sake of tax avoidance. In the same fashion the top management could insist that only a true sale or true collection that brings revenue for the period under consideration is booked as the income. That could be the first step towards recognizing and encouraging honesty.

The problem is not just about managing the book for achieving target. It is about the culture of honesty in our business dealing or even governance. As Laurie Calhoun noted in his article The Problem of “Dirty Hands” and Corrupt Leadership “In thinking about this issue, it is important to distinguish self-serving opportunists from those who suffer corruption through their sincere efforts to govern well. Self-serving opportunists often rationalize their dubious measures to themselves through self-deceptive references to ‘the good of the whole,’ claiming that group loyalty demands moral sacrifice or that ‘the end justifies the means.’”

But we live in Kaliyuga when it is all about managing “The art and ethics of lying” (Read on Part 1 and Part 2)

The truth is never dangerous. Except when told. PHILIP MOELLER

If you like this, shasre it with your friends

Sunday, May 13, 2012

Some People All the Time.. Humour

Major Desai retired from the army and returned to his hometown. Many people wondered with the kind of network he claimed to have and the heroism in the wars that he boasted about why he did not go further up at least to be a brigadier. As per him he had got bored of being in the army and hence he decided to quit and be back where he belonged. Of course there are few skeptics who raise their eyebrows on this claim. Maybe they are just jealous of his charm and popularity; especially with the Municipal commissioner and the local Sub Inspector who are his drinking buddies.

In the second month after he returned home, his neighbor came and asked him whether he had any way to find out the results of the soldier selection in Indian Army, Neighbor’s son had appeared for the selection. Major Desai remembered that one of his old buddies Havildar Sharma from the army may be able to find out about the results. Havildar Sharma helped him and gave him list of all the five young lads who qualified from Major Desai’s home town. Major promptly informed all the five families and they were all impressed by the ‘connects’ Major Desai had. Now for the whole town Desai became Major Saab.

In the next selection season many parents approached Major Saab in advance to seek help for their lads. He offered to help on two conditions. He will first evaluate these lads as he would not like to recommend nincompoops to the Army. He should be given Rs 1 lac in advance for each lad who passes his evaluation. The money was not for him; but to make some in the selection committee happy! But he promised that he would return the money of those who do not get selected.

He interviewed about 30 lads and agreed to recommend for 10. When the selection team came to town he was there at the ground where physical examination was being held. He walked up to Captain who was the team leader shook hands and introduced himself. They had few army jokes to share. Major Saab of course knew by name many a colonels and brigadier’s who were his ‘batch mates’. Capt was impressed. The lads from his town saw Major Saab pointing his hands in their direction and were convinced that he had put in a word to the captain. Actually, Major Saab was describing the story about the temple that was behind the ground in the same direction as the prospective soldiers were standing. After these pleasantries Major Saab returned home.

When the selection process was completed, Havildar Sharma informed Major Saab in advance, before the results were announced, about the outcome. Seven lads from his town were selected. Out of these, five were from the lot who paid him. He met the parents of the other two and told them that they would not be selected unless some action is taken immediately. He asked for Rs 2 lac for each with the promise that he would return the money if they were not selected. Of course they were selected Five out of the original 10 who had paid him were also selected. Major Saab was a gentleman. He returned 1 lac to all the five who did not get selected. He made sure that every other person in the town knew about what he did for the lads of the town. Municipal commissioner arranged a felicitation ceremony in his honor.

Major Saab is not an exception.We come across some in all walks of life. When the stakes are high very often Major Saabs appear to manage a lead. Most of us have a small Major Saab hiding in us too, though we feel ashamed to let him loose. But then it is for us to choose! 


Shame is like everything else; live with it for long enough and it becomes part of the furniture. SALMAN RUSHDIE,




If you like this post, share it with your friends

Sunday, August 28, 2011

Outcome or Process, Choose One


IT enabled Governance (ITeG) is gaining acceptance and momentum. The Electronic Service Delivery Bill now under consideration of the government is expected to give further thrust to e-enablement. With Aadhaar (unique id) getting better traction, Aadhaar integration in the service delivery also is providing stimulus in ITeG initiatives.

The complexity and challenges relating to the e-enablement vary across departments. On one end of the spectrum, the processes are quite mature and well defined, and computerization is primarily a means for improvement in productivity. On the other end of the spectrum, what is required is not just automation of existing processes, but a total transformation solution which involves significant process re-engineering, re-alignment of the role of various stakeholders which may also result in some stake holders role getting redundant or less important, innovative use of technology, phased implementation, continuous monitoring and many mid-course corrections.

In both cases Information Technology is a critical component; but often it is forgotten that IT is a means to an end and not and end in itself. I do not intend to discuss the other dimensions of ITeG in this post (take a look at ‘An amateur’s guide to e-Governance”). This note is about how the IT component is managed by government departments. Most government departments have limited in house skill to undertake these activities and therefore they outsource these to private sector service providers. Most of the IT service providers who take up these jobs of the System Integrators often do not have a total solution orientation or they are not capable to offer one. So they end up being suppliers to staff.

The predominant skill set for them is writing software for the specification given by the solution architects because our domestic software industry is often drunk with the $ from being technicians and cybercoolies and not architects and engineers. The user requirement study is "Tell me what exactly you want me to automate, I will program it" and not "Tell me what your dream is, we will work together on how technology can make it happen". So their approach is that of manpower provider than a solution provider. They don’t share the risk of a failed system (the limitation of liability clause adequately takes care of this) nor do the government comfortable to share the reward in the form of outcome based payments.

Often service providers influence how the RFP is made which ends up being an enquiry for supply of bodies than outcomes. So RFP gives more importance to the CV of the team instead of making them responsible for the outcome. Subsequently these contracts make the client to pay for rectifying the bugs in the programs and also make him spent for much more hardware than needed. Augmenting this problem is the purchase decision based on the lowest price quoted by the vendors. No proper matrices for measuring the outcome are defined and the department attempts to micromanage the CV, the attendance, hardware specification and so on. Then either the shoddy service providers takes the contract or the selected vendor develops shoddy solutions. That is the reason many ITeG don’t live up to the expectations.

When people are told exactly what and how to do something, they stop thinking for themselves-and they can't learn and grow. ~ unknown

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Death by Power Point

Couple of weeks back I attended a conference. As the key note speaker we had an expert from one of the top notch institutions in the world, who had recently relocated from London. As the topic was close to my heart, I parked myself in the front seat. The speaker had a distinct western accent as he had been out of the country for a long time.

As expected from any expert speaker today, he had a power point presentation to support his talk. The slides started moving one by one. Extremely colorful, quite complex diagrams with wide variety of shapes and colours linked and interlinked using arrows and lines flowing in and out and very densely packed text. Quite visually impressive!

Even front row, I found it difficult to read most of the text. The message that was expected to be understood from the various cubes, pyramids and animations were too complex for me to follow; especially when I attempted to follow the speech. The speaker expected me to quickly assimilate each slide in milliseconds and then connect it to the pearls of wisdom that came from his mouth.

The audio and the visuals were impressive; but, failed to communicate to the audience. This is a phenomenon that has become quite common these days. Power Point presentation is a killer utility that Computer revolution has contributed to the modern day manager. With more and more functionalities and features Power Point has become more important to corporate executives than even food and water. (The only other killer functionality that can beat this is the is ‘copy paste’ function)

A good Power Point presentation can be a powerful tool to make penetrating communications; especially in presentations. It can help the presenter as cue card to help in keeping a structured story line, it can pictorially present some difficult concepts, it can help the audience to quickly refer to the broader context of what is being presented so on and so forth

But overuse of the funky features is making this to a tool that kills effective communication. Power Point helps in building excellent visual presentations and diagrammatic representations.

The diagrams pie charts we use as a part of a written document can afford to be a bit complex and dense (though I would not recommend overdose of it). This is because the reader has the flexibility to read the text, look at the model, ruminate and go back to the text and the model again if he feels the need. In this case he sets the pace. Even when we provide an electronic copy of the presentation and the receiver can view it at his pace, we can afford to have some element of complexity.

But if we are using our PPT as a complement to our oral presentation we cannot afford such complex and dense slide show. If our presentation is to a small audience who are very much clued on to the topic we are presenting (say our department colleagues, our board, our client) we can get away with some of these gimmicks.

But if we are making a presentation to a larger audience then these colorful animations dampens the effectiveness of the presentation. Very often when we make presentations and the speeches to a large audience, the level to which most of the people are clued into the topic will be to a much lesser extent. In such circumstances, if we make our PPT and speech complex and heavy, it will fail to communicate though it may appear erudite. The complex slide deck will then become a distraction. Human beings cannot listen, read and assimilate complex messages in real time as his working memory have limited capacity and has limited duration, especially when it comes to new and novel information. The visuals could act as an intuitive complement; but, if it is anything more, it can be very frustrating and ineffective. What is worse is the presenter referring to the slides all the time taking away one of the most important component of oral presentation; the eye contact.

The new breed “MBA” varieties (I can vouch for that. I am one too) who are computer savvy (A very critical skill these days) get carried away by everything the computer can do without assessing how useful and how relevant they are in the context. The slide deck for them becomes a tool to intimidate, a means to prove how smart they are and not an aid to communicate and to relate. But in reality they become crutches to the speaker and not an aid to the audience. Should we consider banning power point presentation? Absolutely not; if we do that there will be many more (like consultants) to join Dodo as an extinct species.(don’t deny me my daily bread)

"If your words or images are not on point, making them dance in color won't make them relevant." - Edward Tufte Professor Emeritus, Yale University

If you like this post, share it with your friends

Monday, June 27, 2011

Caveat Emptor ?

The bank was taken aback by the order of the IT secretary of Tamilnadu as the adjudicator under the Information Technology Act, when he directed the bank to pay Rs 12.85 lacs as the compensation to an Abu Dhabi based NRI for the loss suffered by him in a “Phishing Fraud” . (1)

“Phishing” is a security risk that many computer users are getting to be familiar. In this case the account holder received an email that appeared genuine, which asked him to provide the use rid and password for his internet banking account to avoid his account getting closed. He parted with these details and he lost about Rs 7,00,000 from his account.

The bank took a view that the loss is on account of the carelessness of the account holder and refused any compensation as they had advised all account holders not to part with their userid and password to anybody. How could he be so irresponsible and give away his password and then claim that the bank should compensate him? But the adjudicator did not agree to this point of view.

This is an interesting dilemma for all entities like banks and depositories that provide online service to their clients. Where does their liability end for the loss suffered by their clients? Under what circumstances will they continue to be liable even if the loss was the outcome of a failure by the account holder?

Similar issues have been there with respect to offline transactions too. For example the loss suffered by credit card holders on account of misuse of their card details or loss of money from the bank account by fraudulent instructions.

One of the accepted doctrines in legal theory is that the entity that is best equipped to manage the risk should be liable to the loss arising out of such risk. This doctrine has been followed not just in online transaction. It has been used in fixing liability in terms of workplace accidents, accidents in amusement park and and so on.

For many this may look very unfair. Shouldn’t the responsibility of the service provider end when it has put in place risk containment measures and warned the users about the potential risks? Why should it bear the brunt of a fraud when ingenious souls manage to find a way around the protective walls?

There are studies comparing the incidents of banking frauds between the countries that placed the primary responsibility on the service provider and on the customer. These studies showed that when the legal structure supported the above doctrine the extent of fraud was much less. The service providers continuously upgraded their risk containment systems as they could not hide behind “fine prints” in the forms that they make their clients sign and the disclaimers that they publish. They cannot limit their risk with firewalls and dematerialized zones in their data centers. They have no option but innovative in saving their clients from their own foolishness. They are forced to look for patterns, trends, exceptions, track locations from where the transaction originate, raise alert when exceptions occur and so on. But if still a client is faced with a loss, he is compensated unless they can prove the customer connivance or involvement. We can’t just declare “Caveat Emptor”.

Risk mangment therefore becomes a managerial decision, may be more than technical solutions. (Read on Digital Security – Business, People and Economics for some more thoughts on this)

Ref: (1) https://indialawnews.org/tag/human-rights/

"Customers don't expect you to be perfect. They do expect you to fix things when they go wrong." Donald Porter, British Airways

If you like this post, share it with your friends