Take it or leave it

“How do you expect us to fly as you fly?” came another voice. “You are special and gifted and divine, above other birds.”
“Touched him with a wingtip! Brought him to life! The Son of the Great Gull!”
“No! He denies it! He’s a devil! DEVIL! Come to break the Flock!”
- Jonathan Livingston Seagull

Shashi Tharoor had right credentials for being in the external affairs ministry. Well educated, excellent experience in the field of international diplomacy, an outstanding orator, a thinker, and well connected among the senior political and administrative circles across the world. However, the self righteous middle class and the many among the self serving media together were too eager to pillory him for his ‘cattle class” remark and were happy to pull him down for his IPL imbroglio.

C. B. Bhave is the most qualified to hold the position of SEBI Chairman today and he takes his job very seriously. The enforcement record of SEBI under his leadership in the last three years has been outstanding in comparison to its past performance. The initiatives he took in with respect to the mutual fund industry and the insurance industry have been acknowledged as beneficial for the investors at large. But there are many out there who strongly believe that his ‘tough cop’ style is not what we need in a regulator.

If we look around, we can see many such examples of ‘A few Good Men’ being crucified. When a regular human being like each of us, takes pride in his public responsibility and works hard to do justice to what he is expected to do, there are hardly few who will support him. We seem to be unable to tolerate him for his sense of purpose, his sense of integrity, his initiative in doing the right thing. We are looking for one apparent mistake from his part, one controversy, or one remark, to belittle him if not condemn him.

Why are we so eager to see him flounder? Why are we too happy to see him fail? Why don’t we want him to succeed? Because if he does, then we have no excuse for our inaction; we have no excuse for our failures; we have no excuse for not even trying.

On the other hand, we are willing to tolerate unscrupulous elements in their positions of power, whether in Politics, Bureaucracy, Business or even Academics. The more unscrupulous they are, the more our tolerance. We are willing to extol that iota of good deed that he does as an excuse for our support or at least tolerance of him. We find it easy to elect Phulan Devi and Haji Mastan (I am sure we can think of better living examples around us) to power than to support and encourage honest and clean officers in their endeavours.

Why? Because he is not one of us; he is an exception, an outlier, an aberration. Our middle class morality can satisfy our self righteousness by dissecting his corruption, fraud and self serving behaviours and attribute his success to his shenanigans. We secretly hope that being on his right side would help us in our own little scams when it is convenient to us.

If we want to try to make a difference we are faced with limited options. Be ready to be called a Devil or God. Or be ready to be shot down by own kith and kin. The more pioneering our initiatives and/ or more change it brings to the existing order more vicious will be the rejection. But we have to keep trying because it is through the sacrifices of a few that social transformation is nurtured; albeit very very slowly.

“Don’t be harsh on them, Fletcher Seagull. In casting you out, the other gulls have only hurt themselves, and one day they will know this, and one day they will see what you see .Forgive them, and help them to understand.” Jonathan Livingston Seagull by Richard Bach


The post represents my personal opinion and not that of any organisations or people with whom I am associated.